Home > The Third Sector > Should Volunteering Be Compulsory for Adolescents?

Should Volunteering Be Compulsory for Adolescents?

By: Joanne Walker BA (hons) - Updated: 26 Oct 2010 | comments*Discuss
 
Volunteering Voluntary Charity Pros Cons

The issue of whether or not volunteering should be compulsory for adolescents is no cut and dried issue. Although on the face of it it may seem like a good idea to have all teenagers in the country doing some kind of charity work, there are also plenty of reasons why some people think it could be a bad idea as well. The coalition government has announced a programme whereby young people will carry out voluntary work as part of a national scheme – and the Prime Minister has suggested that at some point it will become so normal that volunteering will a rite of passage for youngsters. But just what are the pros and cons of sending all teenagers out to do charity work?

Pros

The first pro which springs to mind is one which the age of teenagers makes very appropriate. Volunteering is a great tool to finding work. It teaches young people responsibility, teamwork and numerous other life skills. Volunteering could also be tailored to the world of work they would like to go into – and therefore, teach them specialised skills they can utilise in their future life. And by volunteering, young people show they are willing to help others and give up their own time for the greater good.

A second, major factor in society these days, is that by giving youngsters something to do, it stops them from getting into trouble. A much mooted phrase, getting into trouble is one which is used by many people to describe what all teenagers do. Of course, nothing could be further from the truth and those young people which do get into trouble are not the majority by any stretch of the imagination. However, by having a scheme whereby youngsters can occupy themselves, even that minority will be given something to do – either keeping them out of trouble by filling their time, or by giving them a sense of worth.

Cons

Whilst volunteering is a good way of showing employers that a person is worth taking on, a compulsory scheme would diminish the value of this somewhat. In fact, making volunteering compulsory almost changes the very meaning of it as no-one would then be able to show that they are volunteering for the greater good or because they want to learn new skills. In fact, young people who wanted to illustrate that they actually wanted to volunteer would end up doing twice as much as the scheme demanded to prove this.

The other problem with forcing young people to volunteer is that in some young people, it may have the opposite of the desired effect – that is to say, they may well rebel against it and come to resent the scheme. Therefore, they will get very little from their voluntary work and it may even send them on a wayward path.

Because we do not have a volunteering scheme which is compulsory, it is hard to say exactly what the effects of one would be. Many people believe that National Service is something which should be brought back and that volunteering is the next best thing. But the cons of such a scheme do mean that the very nature of volunteering would be taken away somewhat and volunteering as it is in its current form would cease to exist.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Topics
Latest Comments
  • KWAME OTENG
    Re: Questionnaire: Do You Have Time to Be a Volunteer?
    Great interpretation of results. However, various optional interpretations and generalization are not…
    24 August 2019
  • Hugh mungus
    Re: Good Citizenship
    I was denied citizenship because i am black, why is this
    10 June 2019
  • Majaani
    Re: The Role of Volunteers
    Hello I would like to have volunteers to visit my organisation called the NISSI PROJECT, found in Uganda, Africa,we care about orphans and…
    28 November 2018
  • non
    Re: Being a Responsible Citizen
    you should adress the goverment departments and agencies they will manipulate situations , for thier benefit and outcome , and…
    21 January 2018
  • Tunji Rhema
    Re: Being a Responsible Citizen
    I love this topic. This is what I have been preaching as an NGO. And the act of being responsible is transferable. Children watch…
    28 November 2017
  • Laudonya
    Re: The Role of Volunteers
    I desire to receive volunteers to my community. I need my community to be empowered and helped to reduce crime.We have an organization…
    20 October 2017